← All posts

Gear

Best winter cycling gloves by region, rated

By Paul Rudy · Everett, WA · November 16, 2026

Cold hands end more winter rides than cold legs. The right glove depends a lot on where you ride: a glove that works on a dry 30°F Denver morning can leave you soaked and frozen in a 40°F Seattle downpour. So I sorted this guide by region, using NOAA climate normals for each area and the gloves that professional testers rated best for those conditions.

To be clear up front: I have not tested these gloves myself. Every warmth, waterproofing and fit claim below comes from published, hands-on reviews, linked in the sources. Here's what the testers found, plus a simple score out of 10 so you can compare them.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Some links below are affiliate links (Amazon tag: travlnbike-20). Buying through them supports the channel at no extra cost to you. Prices change and Amazon prices vary by size and color, so check the product page before you buy. Prices below were checked on November 16, 2026.

The short version

Pacific Northwest: wet cold

Seattle, January normals: 48.0°F / 37.7°F high/low, 5.78 in of precipitation, and 12.7 days with 0.10 in or more of rain [15]. In plain terms: average lows stay above freezing, but it's wet for weeks.

This is my home weather in Everett. The problem here is not extreme cold, it's water. Insulation that gets soaked stops working, so waterproofing matters more than raw warmth. Bicycling also points out that in humid places you want better wind and water protection at the expense of breathability [1].

Top pick: everyday wet riding

Endura Deluge 7/10

Five-finger, waterproof membrane · Backed by 1 tested source [5][6]

BikeRadar: "brilliant in the rain" and close to the perfect winter glove for cold, wet riding. Low bulk, good bar feel, worked with Di2 buttons and a Garmin touchscreen. The palms can get damp in heavy rain but the tester's hands never got cold. Slim fit may not suit wide hands. No tested temperature was given.

Price checked November 16, 2026: $26.99 on sale at BikeTiresDirect (list $70)

Budget pick: the worst near-freezing rain

Glacier Glove Ice Bay 9/10

Fleece-lined 2 mm neoprene · Backed by 1 tested source [1]

Bicycling's pick for near-freezing rain: "as waterproof as any piece of clothing could be", with very good dexterity for the warmth. It does not breathe at all, so hands get sweaty, and if you take the gloves off mid-ride they go cold fast. Wear a thin liner inside (Velo's advice for neoprene).

Price checked November 16, 2026: $39.99 at Glacier Glove (regular $47.99)

When to step up: if you commute daily in the rain, Bar Mitts over a lighter glove keep wind and spray off your hands; Cycling Weekly's tester rides in the Pacific Northwest [9]. On rides over about three hours in steady rain, pack a second dry pair, because every glove eventually wets out [2].

Northeast and Mid-Atlantic: damp cold, rain and snow

January normals: Boston 36.8°F / 23.1°F, New York (Central Park) 39.5°F / 27.9°F, Philadelphia 41.3°F / 26.0°F. About 6 to 7 days a month with 0.10 in or more of precipitation, and Boston averages 14.30 in of snow in January [15].

Rides here swing between wet 40s and raw 20s, often with high humidity. Bicycling notes that a glove that's fine at a given temperature in dry Colorado can feel too cold in the Northeast because of the humidity [1]. Look for a real membrane plus insulation.

Top pick: warmest and driest five-finger

GripGrab Polaris 2 6/10

Five-finger, PrimaLoft Gold, 3-layer waterproof membrane · Backed by 2 tested sources [2][12]

Cyclingnews' heavy-duty five-finger pick with "very good waterproofing". Matos Vélo's tester never felt cold at 27°F (−3°C) and says hours of steady rain did not get through, but found them too warm above about 41°F (5°C). A little bulky, and expensive.

Price checked November 16, 2026: $110 at GripGrab

Budget pick (and the top score overall)

Giro Xnetic H2O 9/10

Five-finger, waterproof membrane · Backed by 1 tested source [7]

A Cycling Weekly tester was fine for 90 minutes at 30°F (−1°C) and rode a snowy day at 21 to 27°F with only brief cold fingertips, though Giro rates it to 41°F. Light, packable, touchscreen friendly. The outer fabric gets waterlogged in long, heavy rain.

Price checked November 16, 2026: $54.95 at Giro

When to step up: on dry days in the 20s, a lobster glove like the AmFIB (below) is warmer than any five-finger glove [2][3]. Assos Winter Gloves P1 are another strong, lower-bulk option for dry cold if you can stretch to $115 (road.cc 9/10) [10].

Upper Midwest and Great Lakes: deep cold

January normals: Minneapolis-St. Paul 23.6°F / 8.8°F, Chicago (O'Hare) 31.6°F / 18.8°F, with about 11 in of January snow at both [15]. Average lows are well under 20°F, before wind chill.

Here warmth wins. Cyclingnews puts it simply: a five-finger glove will never be the warmest option, so if your fingers struggle, go lobster [2]. None of the sources I read tested any glove in single digits, so for the coldest mornings, plan on stacking: pogies plus a warm glove.

Top pick: lobster glove for below freezing

Pearl Izumi AmFIB Lobster Gel 7/10

Lobster (split-finger), PrimaLoft Gold · Backed by 3 tested sources [1][3][4]

The deep-cold pick from three sources. The MTB Lab stayed comfortable at 20 to 25°F, Bicycling wears them below freezing, and Cyclingnews calls them warmer than any five-finger glove it tried. You lose some dexterity off the bike, the liner can pull out with your hand, and Cyclingnews says wet-weather performance isn't great.

Price checked November 16, 2026: $71.25 at Pearl Izumi (regular $95)

Budget move: Bar Mitts over gloves you already own

Bar Mitts (pogies) 6/10

Neoprene handlebar mitts, worn over gloves · Backed by 2 tested sources [1][9]

Not a glove: they wrap your bar, shifters and brake levers. Cycling Weekly's Pacific Northwest tester rode in sub-freezing temperatures wearing gloves normally used at 40 to 55°F and still got warm, and says they made riding possible despite Raynaud's symptoms. Bicycling notes you can't ride in the drops. Check the version for your bars and cable routing.

Price checked November 16, 2026: $74.95 at Bar Mitts (road and flat-bar versions)

When to step up: below about 20°F, combine Bar Mitts with the AmFIB or another insulated glove. Cyclingnews also suggests saving a chemical hand warmer for the second half of a ride [2].

Mountain West and Rockies: dry cold, big daily swings

January normals: Denver 44.6°F / 18.7°F with only 1.3 days of 0.10 in or more of precipitation, and Salt Lake City 38.6°F / 24.2°F with 12.70 in of snow [15]. Denver's average January high is about 26°F above its average low.

Dry air changes the math. Bicycling says that in places like Colorado you can often use a lighter, more breathable glove at the same temperature, because it moves sweat away better [1]. Long climbs followed by cold descents also reward gloves that breathe and don't get clammy.

Top pick: warm without bulk

Assos Winter Gloves P1 7/10

Five-finger, insulated, water-repellent · Backed by 2 tested sources [1][10]

Thin and low bulk but warm. Bicycling's tester mountain biked in them near freezing, and road.cc's tester stayed warm in "very cold and windy conditions" with enough rain protection for grim days. Excellent fit and dexterity. The catch is price.

Price checked November 16, 2026: $115 at BikeTiresDirect

Budget pick: high-output rides and shoulder season

Pearl Izumi Summit Alpha 8/10

Thin five-finger, Polartec Alpha insulation · Backed by 1 tested source [8]

Only about 40 g a pair. The tester's hands stayed comfortable around 35°F as long as the tester kept moving, and Cycling Weekly suggests 35 to 55°F after testing. Excellent bar feel and dexterity. Breathability lags on hard efforts, and it is not a deep-winter glove.

Price checked November 16, 2026: $45 at Pearl Izumi (regular $60)

When to step up: for sub-20°F starts, a lobster glove or pogies for the first hour, then swap to the lighter pair as it warms. A thin glove like the DeFeet Duraglove also works as a liner under a bigger glove [11].

South and Southwest: cool mornings

January normals: Atlanta 54.0°F / 35.6°F, Austin 62.5°F / 41.8°F, Phoenix 67.6°F / 46.0°F [15]. Average lows from the mid 30s to mid 40s, highs from the mid 50s to upper 60s.

You mostly need wind protection for the first hour, and something you can stuff in a jersey pocket once it warms up. Heavy insulated gloves will just make your hands sweat.

Top pick: light, windproof, packable

Castelli Perfetto RoS 2 6/10

Light five-finger, windproof Gore-Tex Infinium · Backed by 1 tested source [2][13]

Cyclingnews' lightweight pick: fleece inside, windproof shell, water resistant but not waterproof, "for warmer places" enough for the whole winter. Cyclingnews lists a 39 to 57°F range. Fingers run long. Cyclingnews gave the first-generation Perfetto RoS 5/5; the RoS 2 has not been scored by a source I read.

Price checked November 16, 2026: $63.75 on sale at BikeTiresDirect (list $85)

Budget pick: dry, cool mornings

DeFeet Duraglove ET Wool 6/10

Knit merino blend, no membrane · Backed by 2 tested sources [1][11]

Bicycling's 50°F pick: grippy, breathable, touchscreen friendly, fine into the low 40s on hard rides. No windproofing and it soaks up rain. road.cc found it slim enough to wear under bigger gloves as a liner, and a little short in the fingers.

Price checked November 16, 2026: $29.99 at DeFeet

When to step up: Atlanta averages 7.3 wet days in January [15]. If you ride in cold rain, the Summit Alpha or Xnetic H2O above handle damp far better than a knit glove, which soaks through [1][7][8].

When to step up: lobster, pogies or liners

All ratings in one table

Sorted by score. Ties are broken by how many tested sources back the glove, then by price. Scroll the table sideways on a phone.

#GloveScoreWarmthWaterDexterityFitValueTested sources (confidence)Published review scorePrice checked November 16, 2026
1Glacier Glove Ice Bay
Fleece-lined 2 mm neoprene
9/10222121 (Lower) [1]No numeric score published$39.99 at Glacier Glove (regular $47.99)
2Giro Xnetic H2O
Five-finger, waterproof membrane
9/10212221 (Lower) [7]Cycling Weekly 4.5/5$54.95 at Giro
3Pearl Izumi Summit Alpha
Thin five-finger, Polartec Alpha insulation
8/10112221 (Lower) [8]Cycling Weekly 4/5$45 at Pearl Izumi (regular $60)
4Pearl Izumi AmFIB Lobster Gel
Lobster (split-finger), PrimaLoft Gold
7/10211213 (Higher) [1][3][4]Cyclingnews 4.5/5$71.25 at Pearl Izumi (regular $95)
5Assos Winter Gloves P1
Five-finger, insulated, water-repellent
7/10212202 (Medium) [1][10]road.cc 9/10$115 at BikeTiresDirect
6Endura Deluge
Five-finger, waterproof membrane
7/10122111 (Lower) [5][6]BikeRadar 4.5/5$26.99 on sale at BikeTiresDirect (list $70)
7DeFeet Duraglove ET Wool
Knit merino blend, no membrane
6/10102122 (Medium) [1][11]road.cc 7/10$29.99 at DeFeet
8Bar Mitts (pogies)
Neoprene handlebar mitts, worn over gloves
6/10211112 (Medium) [1][9]Cycling Weekly 4.75/5$74.95 at Bar Mitts (road and flat-bar versions)
9GripGrab Polaris 2
Five-finger, PrimaLoft Gold, 3-layer waterproof membrane
6/10221102 (Medium) [2][12]No numeric score published$110 at GripGrab
10Castelli Perfetto RoS 2
Light five-finger, windproof Gore-Tex Infinium
6/10112111 (Lower) [2][13]Cyclingnews 5/5 (first version)$63.75 on sale at BikeTiresDirect (list $85)

How the scores work

Each glove gets 0, 1 or 2 points in five areas, for a total out of 10. Warmth, waterproofing, dexterity and fit come only from what published testers reported. I did not run my own tests.

Warmth
2 = a tester reports comfortable hands near or below freezing (described that way, or 33°F or colder). 1 = testers call it warm, or comfortable in the mid 30s to low 40s, but report no colder test of this version. 0 = testers say it's for above about 45°F.
Waterproofing
2 = a waterproof membrane or sealed neoprene that testers say kept hands dry or warm through sustained rain. 1 = water resistant: fine in showers and spray, wets out in long rain. 0 = no rain protection, soaks through.
Dexterity
2 = testers praise bar feel or dexterity with no complaint. 1 = testers note a trade-off (lobster design, bulk, fewer hand positions). 0 = testers say controls are hard to work.
Fit
2 = testers praise the fit or call it true to size. 1 = no fit comment, or a caveat (slim, long or short fingers, needs the right version for your bike). 0 = fit is a main complaint.
Value
Based on the regular (non-sale) price on a retailer or brand page I checked on November 16, 2026. 2 = $60 or less. 1 = $60.01 to $100. 0 = over $100.
Confidence
How many separate publications tested the glove: 3 or more = higher, 2 = medium, 1 = lower. Published review scores are shown for reference and are not added into my score.

What the score does not capture: breathability (the Ice Bay doesn't breathe at all) and durability, which most reviews couldn't judge over one season. Read the notes for each glove, not just the number.

Gloves I left out, and why

FAQ

What cycling gloves work best in 35 to 45 degree rain?

For everyday wet riding, testers rate the Endura Deluge highly: BikeRadar called it brilliant in the rain and gave it 4.5 out of 5. For the worst near-freezing downpours, Bicycling reaches for the Glacier Glove Ice Bay, a fleece-lined neoprene glove that is fully waterproof but does not breathe. Commuters can add Bar Mitts over a lighter glove.

When should I switch to lobster or split-finger gloves?

When five-finger gloves leave your fingertips cold, usually around or below freezing. Cyclingnews notes a five-finger glove will never be the warmest option, and The MTB Lab stayed comfortable at 20 to 25 degrees F in the Pearl Izumi AmFIB Lobster Gel. You give up a little dexterity, mostly off the bike.

Are Bar Mitts or pogies worth it?

For cold commutes and sub-freezing rides, testers say yes. A Cycling Weekly tester rode below freezing wearing gloves normally used at 40 to 55 degrees F and still got warm, and rated Bar Mitts 4.75 out of 5. The trade-offs are fewer hand positions (Bicycling notes you cannot ride in the drops) and picking the right version for your bars.

Are any cycling gloves completely waterproof?

Not for hours. Cyclingnews says gloves with a membrane keep hands dry for a while, but ride long enough and they all saturate; only a shell or a fully sealed neoprene glove is truly waterproof. On rides longer than about three hours in rain, carry a dry second pair.

How are these gloves rated?

Each glove gets 0 to 2 points in five areas, warmth, waterproofing, dexterity, fit and value, for a score out of 10. The first four come only from what published testers reported. Value comes from the regular price on a retailer or brand page checked on November 16, 2026. Paul did not test these gloves himself.

Related

Sources

  1. Bicycling (Dan Chabanov). Best Winter Cycling Gloves for Cold, Wet, and Windy Rides, published Nov 12, 2026. Tested 40+ models from the low 60s to below 20°F. Picks taken from the article body; its summary list names different gloves. bicycling.com
  2. Cyclingnews (Tom Wieckowski). Best winter cycling gloves 2026, last updated Sep 10, 2026. cyclingnews.com
  3. Cyclingnews. Pearl Izumi AmFIB Lobster Gel gloves review, Jan 21, 2022. Rated 4.5/5. cyclingnews.com
  4. The MTB Lab. Just In: Gloves from Pearl iZUMi, Kali Protectives, and Nathan Sports, Feb 2021 (first impressions of the AmFIB Lobster Gel). themtblab.com
  5. BikeRadar (Warren Rossiter). Endura Deluge winter gloves review, Jan 8, 2024. Rated 4.5/5. bikeradar.com
  6. BikeRadar. Best winter road cycling and mountain biking gloves for 2026. bikeradar.com
  7. Cycling Weekly. Giro Xnetic H2O Gloves review, Jan 24, 2026. Rated 4.5/5. Also "best overall" in Cycling Weekly's winter glove guide (updated Nov 11, 2026). cyclingweekly.com
  8. Cycling Weekly. Pearl Izumi Summit Alpha Gloves review, Jan 14, 2026. Rated 4/5. cyclingweekly.com
  9. Cycling Weekly (Anne-Marije Rook). Looks be damned: a Type II adventure review of the simply effective Bar Mitts, Feb 14, 2023. Rated 4.75/5. cyclingweekly.com
  10. road.cc. Assos Winter Gloves P1 review, Mar 21, 2026. Overall 9/10. road.cc
  11. road.cc (Steve Williams). DeFeet Duraglove ET Charcoal Wool w/Black Grippies review, Mar 3, 2025. Overall 7/10. road.cc
  12. Matos Vélo (Guillaume Robert). Essai des gants hiver GripGrab Polaris 2 (in French), Jan 30, 2023. matosvelo.fr
  13. Cyclingnews. Castelli Perfetto RoS gloves review (first version), Nov 27, 2022. Rated 5/5. cyclingnews.com
  14. Velo. Glacier Gloves offers neoprene gloves for every winter ride (advice on wearing liners with neoprene). velo.outsideonline.com
  15. NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information. U.S. Climate Normals 1991 to 2020, monthly normals for January (average high, average low, precipitation, days with 0.10 in. or more, snowfall). Stations: Seattle-Tacoma Intl, Boston Logan, New York Central Park, Philadelphia Intl, Minneapolis/St Paul, Chicago O'Hare, Denver Intl, Salt Lake City Intl, Atlanta Hartsfield, Austin Camp Mabry, Phoenix Sky Harbor. ncei.noaa.gov
  16. Prices checked November 16, 2026: Endura Deluge, BikeTiresDirect (www.biketiresdirect.com); Glacier Glove Ice Bay, glacierglove.com (www.glacierglove.com); GripGrab Polaris 2, gripgrab.com (www.gripgrab.com); Giro Xnetic H2O, giro.com (www.giro.com); Pearl Izumi AmFIB Lobster Gel, pearlizumi.com (www.pearlizumi.com); Pearl Izumi Summit Alpha, pearlizumi.com (www.pearlizumi.com); Bar Mitts road version, barmitts.com (barmitts.com); Castelli Perfetto RoS 2, BikeTiresDirect (www.biketiresdirect.com); DeFeet Duraglove ET Wool, defeet.com (www.defeet.com); Assos Winter Gloves P1, BikeTiresDirect (www.biketiresdirect.com). Amazon listings checked the same day; Amazon prices vary by size and color.

Ride in a glove you love that isn't here? Tell me on YouTube, or find more at travlnbike.com.

Ride warm,
Paul